Indian Company Investor Calls

Avanti Feed PBT Falls 52% as Costs Crush Margins

Avanti Feeds Limited — Q2 FY27 — November 20, 2026

The call reviewed unaudited results for the quarter and half-year ended September 30, 2026.

1. Overall Tone of Management

Cautious, with defensive elements. Management repeatedly described FY27 as challenging, cited sharp raw-material inflation, tariffs, weather and disease risks, and acknowledged that feed margins were at their lowest. It offered some near-term volume optimism from farmer restocking, but did not quantify a margin recovery or give a clear timeline for one. The call’s optimism about long-term aquaculture prospects is outweighed by deteriorating current economics and downward revisions to industry expectations.

2. Key Themes from Management Commentary

  • Feed profitability is under severe pressure. Feed sales rose year on year, but feed PBT fell 52% in Q2. Management attributed this to sharply higher fishmeal, soybean meal and other input costs, with limited ability to pass increases through without making shrimp farming uneconomic.
  • The industry outlook has weakened. Management cut its estimate for Indian shrimp exports in FY27 from about 90,000 MT to 70,500 MT, citing cyclones, floods and disease. Estimated shrimp feed consumption was also reduced from 11–12 lakh MT to about 10 lakh MT.
  • Tariffs are weighing on shrimp processing economics. Management said US import duties total about 21%—anti-dumping duty, countervailing duty and Section 301 tariffs—and that higher freight also reduced processing-division PBT.
  • Market diversification and value addition remain strategic priorities. The company cited Europe, Japan, the Middle East and Korea as markets to develop, while noting that policy benefits from trade agreements are not yet in effect.
  • Pet food remains an early-stage investment. Sales grew sequentially, distribution and marketing are expanding, and approvals for the Hyderabad facility have been obtained. Construction is now planned, but current sales remain small.
  • Capital allocation remains conservative. Management said surplus funds have supported working capital and raw-material inventory; it does not currently foresee shareholder distributions.

3. Q&A Analysis

A. Feed demand, price increases and margin outlook

  • Analysts asked: Are farmers continuing to stock despite inflation? Has Avanti raised feed prices? Are margins near a trough, and when might they recover?
  • Management responded: Farmers were still cultivating because farmgate prices were stable and profitable; restocking was underway after flood-related early harvests. Avanti took an Rs 8/kg increase in October, described as roughly 8%. Management expected stronger feed consumption in the current quarter and Q4 if stocking holds.
  • Notable answer: Management explicitly agreed that the company was “currently at the lowest margin,” but would not forecast feed EBITDA per kg or identify FY28 as a recovery year. It said outcomes depend on raw materials, seasonality and weather.
  • Quote: “We cannot say whether it will be 5, 3, or 2 rupees.”

B. Raw-material inflation and policy intervention

  • Analysts asked: Would fishmeal and soybean meal remain expensive, and could government intervention bring costs down?
  • Management responded: El Niño was disrupting crops and fishmeal supply. Industry groups had requested fishmeal export controls or quotas and temporary soybean-meal imports; the latter had received a “lukewarm” government response. Management did not expect significant input-cost relief for the rest of FY27.
  • Assessment: The answers were detailed on the causes and representations, but offered no actionable cost-reduction timeline. Management’s earlier expectation of stabilization has shifted to accepting that high costs may persist through the year.

C. Shrimp exports, tariffs and market economics

  • Analysts asked: Why was the company’s export target reduced from 19,000 MT to 17,500 MT? What is the current US duty burden, and how do margins compare across markets?
  • Management responded: It cited longer transit times and higher stock in transit, and gave US duties of about 21% in total. It declined to compare duties across countries during the call, asking the analyst to send a request by email. Management said China generally yields lower margins than the US, while market profitability otherwise depends on customer mix.
  • Notable answer: Asked whether the US remained the most lucrative market, management rejected that characterization: “I would not say that.”

D. US tariff refunds

  • Analysts asked: When will the company receive refunds on tariffs previously paid?
  • Management responded: The US refund mechanism exists, but entries have not been liquidated; pending legal reviews relating to anti-dumping matters remain. The company has received no substantial refund and has no timeline.
  • Assessment: The expected refund remains uncertain and should not be treated as near-term cash flow.

E. Fish-feed project and capital allocation

  • Analysts asked: What is the status of the fish-feed project, and would Avanti distribute surplus cash?
  • Management responded: It has not made a firm decision on fish feed because market economics and product mix are unclear. It said working-capital needs and raw-material purchases justify retaining cash, with no distribution planned at this time.
  • Assessment: The fish-feed project is explicitly delayed; the company gave no decision date.

F. Trade agreements

  • Analysts asked: Are FTAs already improving export prospects?
  • Management responded: Agreements with Europe and the UK were described as promising, but management is waiting for them to take effect before assessing actual benefits.

4. Guidance / Outlook

Quantitative guidance

  • FY27 feed sales: Around 580,000 MT in prepared remarks, versus about 585,000 MT indicated in the Q1 call. First-half sales were 346,739 MT.
  • FY27 company shrimp exports: Estimated at about 17,500 MT, down from the earlier 19,000 MT aspiration.
  • FY27 Indian shrimp exports: Revised to about 70,500 MT, from an earlier expectation of around 90,000 MT.
  • FY27 industry feed consumption: Now estimated at about 10 lakh MT, versus the earlier 11–12 lakh MT estimate.
  • Pet-food sales: Q2 sales were Rs 202 lakh, up from Rs 180 lakh in Q1. No forward revenue target was provided.

Qualitative signals

  • Management expects restocking to support feed demand in the current quarter and Q4, subject to weather, disease and crop conditions.
  • It expects no significant reduction in raw-material prices for the rest of the year; any stabilization is conditional on El Niño easing and better future crops and fish availability.
  • Pet-food facility construction is planned after land conversion and required approvals were completed.
  • FTA benefits and tariff refunds remain subject to external implementation and regulatory processes.
  • No margin-recovery target or timeline was given.

5. Standout Statements

  • “I would say that we are currently at the lowest margin.”
  • “We do not foresee any significant reduction in prices, and the current situation is likely to continue.”
  • Management cut the FY27 Indian shrimp-export estimate from roughly 90,000 MT to 70,500 MT and feed-consumption expectations from 11–12 lakh MT to 10 lakh MT.
  • “An increase in feed prices beyond a certain level would make shrimp culture non-profitable and unviable for shrimp farmers.”
  • The company’s Q2 feed PBT fell 52% year on year, despite higher feed revenue and higher first-half sales volume.

6. Red Flags / Positive Signals

Red flags
– Feed PBT and margins have deteriorated sharply; management says margins are at the cycle low but does not quantify recovery.
– Industry shrimp-export and feed-consumption expectations were cut materially.
– Input inflation may persist through the rest of FY27, while feed-price pass-through is constrained by farmer affordability.
– Processing PBT declined year on year amid lower volume, higher freight and increased anti-dumping duty.
– Tariff refunds have no specified timeline; the fish-feed project remains undecided.

Positive signals
– First-half feed sales increased about 8% year on year; management reported farmer restocking in November.
– Farmgate shrimp prices were described as high and supportive of farmer profitability.
– Pet-food sales increased sequentially, and the company says required approvals for its manufacturing facility have been obtained.
– Management is pursuing market diversification and value-added products to reduce US-market dependence.

7. Historical Comparison & Consistency Analysis

a. Quarter-by-Quarter Tone Evolution

Q3 FY26 — March 2026
– Dominant tone: Optimistic
– Major themes this quarter:
– Stronger year-on-year feed and processing profitability.
– Expected recovery in feed volumes and at least 10% feed-volume growth.
– Optimism about US tariff relief and improved access to the UK and EU.
– Rising fishmeal and soybean-meal costs acknowledged as a risk.
– Tone shift vs previous quarter: N/A (baseline)

Q4 FY26 — June 2026
– Dominant tone: Neutral
– Major themes this quarter:
– Record seafood exports and positive expectations for the coming shrimp season.
– Steep raw-material inflation and plans for feed-price increases.
– Tariff changes, market diversification and expected export growth.
– Pet-food brand building and preparation for a manufacturing facility.
– Tone shift vs previous quarter: More Cautious
– What changed:
– Input-cost inflation became a central concern, and management warned feed pricing required a balance with farmer affordability.
– Despite positive market-access expectations, management said it could not yet set a reliable budget or detailed growth targets.

Q1 FY27 — August 2026
– Dominant tone: Neutral
– Major themes this quarter:
– Feed volumes and farmer activity were described as strong.
– Raw-material inflation was already compressing feed profitability.
– Management expected monsoon conditions to ease El Niño effects and stabilize inputs.
– Company feed-sales guidance was around 585,000 MT; shrimp-export guidance remained around 19,000 MT.
– Tone shift vs previous quarter: More Cautious
– What changed:
– Feed PBT fell sharply year on year despite higher sales; management confirmed a roughly 10% price increase and anticipated further pressure in Q2.
– The expectation that weather and fresh crops would help stabilize input costs remained an important support to the outlook.

Q2 FY27 — November 2026
– Dominant tone: Pessimistic
– Major themes this quarter:
– Lowest-margin conditions and steep input-cost inflation.
– Cyclones, floods and disease reducing expected shrimp output and exports.
– Higher US duties and freight pressure on shrimp processing.
– Continued investment in pet food, but delayed decisions on fish feed.
– Tone shift vs previous quarter: More Cautious
– What changed:
– The prior expectation that El Niño effects and raw-material prices would ease was replaced by an expectation that high prices could persist through FY27.
– Industry export and feed-consumption estimates were cut, and the company reduced its shrimp-export ambition from 19,000 MT to 17,500 MT.
– Management moved from general margin-pressure warnings to explicitly stating margins were at their lowest, while declining to forecast a recovery.

Trajectory Summary: The tone moved from optimism about tariff relief and a stronger season in Q3 FY26 to caution as input costs rose, then weakened further in Q2 FY27 as weather disruptions and tariffs contributed to lower industry forecasts. The clearest inflection is the reversal of the earlier expectation that El Niño-related cost pressure would ease during FY27.

b. Tracking Past Commitments vs Outcomes

  • FY26 feed sales: Management estimated about 555,000 MT in Q3 FY26; reported FY26 sales were 562,060 MT. ✅ Delivered
  • FY26 feed PBT margin: Management forecast about 14.5%–15% in Q3 FY26; the subsequent Q4 call cited a FY26 feed PBT margin of about 15.5%. ✅ Delivered (slightly above guidance)
  • FY27 feed sales: Guidance shifted from about 585,000 MT in Q1 to about 580,000 MT in the current call. First-half volume was 346,739 MT, but the full-year result is not yet known. ⏳ Revised; outcome pending
  • FY27 company shrimp exports: The prior aspiration was 19,000 MT; current estimate is 17,500 MT. ❌ Revised down / likely missed
  • FY27 Indian shrimp exports: Q1 expectations were around 90,000 MT; current estimate is 70,500 MT. ❌ Revised down
  • US tariff refund: A prior estimate was roughly USD 15–20 million. The company has not received a substantial amount and has no clear timeline. ⏳ Delayed
  • Fish-feed project: Discussed over prior calls, but management still has not made a firm decision, citing uncertain viability. ⏳ Delayed
  • Pet-food facility: Earlier calls described approvals and construction preparations as ongoing; management now says key approvals are obtained and construction is planned. Construction has not yet been reported as started. ⏳ Progressing, but not yet delivered

c. Narrative Shifts

  • From input-cost stabilization to persistent inflation: Q1 management expected favorable monsoon and fresh crops to stabilize costs; Q2 expects no significant price reduction during the rest of FY27.
  • From volume growth to protecting viability: Earlier emphasis on rising culture activity and growth has shifted toward farmer affordability, cost control and the sustainability of the entire shrimp value chain.
  • From tariff relief to tariff burden: Earlier calls highlighted tariff reversals and potential market-access benefits; the current call emphasizes new duties, anti-dumping exposure and delayed refunds.
  • Pet food remains a long-term growth option, not a near-term earnings driver: Commentary continues to focus on brand reach and facility development; sales remain small.
  • Fish feed has lost momentum: Previously discussed as a potential project, it is now explicitly uncertain and without a firm decision.

d. Consistency & Credibility Signals

Overall credibility: Medium. Management has consistently identified feed inputs and farmer affordability as risks, and has generally explained changes in volume expectations using seasonality, weather or market conditions. However, its expectations for cost stabilization shifted materially: Q1 expected El Niño effects to ease, while Q2 said costs were unlikely to fall meaningfully during FY27. Guidance has also been revised downward for company exports and industry production. Management acknowledged these revisions and the low-margin situation directly, but did not provide a measurable recovery outlook.

e. Evolution of Key Themes

  • Feed margins / raw materials — Deteriorating. Input costs rose quarter after quarter; by Q2 FY27 management described margins as at their lowest and did not expect near-term cost relief.
  • Demand and production — Deteriorating versus earlier expectations. Farmer activity was positive in Q1, but floods, cyclones and disease led to lower industry output and revised estimates in Q2.
  • Shrimp exports and trade — Deteriorating near term; diversification strategy stable. Tariff exposure and lower company export guidance weigh on the outlook, while management continues to pursue other markets and value-added products.
  • Pet food — Gradually improving, but still early. Sales and distribution are growing, and approvals have advanced; manufacturing construction remains ahead.

f. Additional Insights

  • The key risk is not just higher feed costs but a pass-through constraint: raising feed prices too far could undermine farmer economics, limiting margin recovery even if input costs remain high.
  • Sequentially, the narrative has shifted from “costs should stabilize” to “government action is needed” and “no significant reduction” is expected in the near term.
  • Management’s positive Q4 restocking outlook is conditional on no further cyclones or disease, so it does not yet offset the weaker full-year industry assumptions.
  • Q2’s weaker feed profitability is especially notable because first-half feed sales volumes were higher year on year; volume growth is not currently translating into earnings growth.